I went there last Saturday with A-Bob for pizza and beer. Good service, good prices. Appetizers were served within a few minutes of us ordering. We had one appetizer, a 4 topping pizza and 3 beers each and our bill was under $35!
Last night I took the wife and kids there for supper. Once again, it was a good experience. For a family of four we ate for under $60.
Pickett is a little off the beaten path but it's well worth the 10 minute drive from Oshkosh.